Last Friday, in the SMUmind reading group, we read Karen Bennett’s excellent “Exclusion Again” (forthcoming in a OUP collection entitled “Being Reduced”, J.Hohwy & J.Kallestrup, eds.), where she offers a clear characterisation of the Exclusion Problem (EP) about mental causation as arising from the inconsistency of the following five doctrines:
1. DISTINCTNESS: mental events are distinct [...]